The Real YayaCanada
  • Home
  • About
  • Archive
  • Quotes + Pandemic Truth

Sun, not C02, driving "Climate Change"?

7/5/2019

8 Comments

 
Picture
 Image: UNFCCC 25th Anniversary: Climate Action is More Urgent than Ever


Sun, not C02, driving "Climate Change"?

A geologist says it is and that it's going to get colder.

Scaring the little kiddies is a cagey, though ultimately cruel, move on the part of the CO2 preachers. Sales of cell phones and all things plastic will increase, ending up on the ocean floor, poisoning the fish, along with sunscreen (very popular and expensive but harmful to sea-life), and, funnest of all, they'll get lots of days off school and be praised for hollering to their hearts' content.

A few of them may actually love Mother Earth enough that they will want to study to be geologists, and then they might feel somewhat embarrassed and a whole lot duped.

What is Geology and why might geologists be excluded from the Intergovernment Panel on Climate Change (IPCC)? Could it be because they blaspheme the religiosity of CO2?

Here's the latest announcement of the IPCC:

Special Report on Global Warming of 1.5 °C
  • Following the decision of the panel at its 43rd Session to accept the invitation from the UNFCCC, at its 44th Session,  the Panel approved ... an IPCC special report on the impacts of global warming of 1.5 °C above pre-industrial levels and related global greenhouse gas emission pathways, in the context of strengthening the global response to the threat of climate change, sustainable development, and efforts to eradicate poverty.

The UNFCCC is the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.
  • The  UNFCCC report was finalized in October 2018 and concluded that "Climate Action is More Urgent than Ever".
  • The UNFCCC entered into force on 21 March 1994. Today, it has near-universal membership. The 197 countries that have ratified the Convention are called Parties to the Convention...
  • Preventing “dangerous” human interference with the climate system is the ultimate aim of the UNFCCC.

Oh, so that bit about "efforts to eradicate poverty" was just window-dressing?

Presumably, the acronym for "Parties to the Convention" is PTTC --  or PALR in French, and VDU in German ...

There are so many acronyms being tossed around nowadays that I actually have to keep a running definition list for them on my desktop!

"Dangerous human interference" may well refer to Geologists, who are "the very scientists most qualified to speak on climate change," says Dr. Roger Higgs:

ResearchGate: IPCC Intergovernmental Panel On Climate Change next report ... 784 authors, yes 784, but again NO geologists!

Dr. Higgs links us to his "technical note" in which he provides "25 simple bullet points proving CO2 does not cause global warming", but I've decided to reproduce the list here so that I can highlight the parts I found especially interesting.  He titles it:
  • 25 simple bullet points proving CO2 does not cause global warming: by a geologist for a change.
  • Dr Roger Higgs, Geoclastica Ltd, Technical Note 2019-11, 6th April 2019, on ResearchGate
  • Contact rogerhiggs@hotmail.com for literature sources for any of the following ‘Inconvenient Facts’

1) Geologists know climate change unrelated to atmospheric CO2 occurred throughout Earth’s 4.5-billion-year history. Yet the IPCC (United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) has  no geologist s among the hundreds of appointed authors of its Fifth Assessment Report of 2014 and its Sixth Report due in 2022 (see my Technical Note 2019-10). Thus IPCC incredibly lacks both geological input and long-term perspective.

2) IPCC’s very existence relies on public belief in manmade or ‘anthropogenic’ global warming (AGW) by CO2 emissions. Moreover its appointed authors, mostly government and university researchers, are nearly all biased by strong vested interests in AGW, i.e. reputations (publications, lectures) & continuance of salaries & research grants. Similarly, major universities have abandoned their scientific impartiality & integrity by hosting research institutes mandated to confirm & act on AGW, e.g. Grantham Institute (Imperial College), Tyndall Centre.

3) The often-repeated ‘97% consensus among scientists that global warming is man’s fault’ (CO2 emissions) is untrue. It refers in fact to surveys of just a relatively small group of ‘climate scientists’ (a fairly new type of scientist, with strong incentives for bias; see Bullets 2 & 15), moreover only those who are ‘actively publishing’.

4) ‘Climate change denier’ & ‘global warming denier’ are despicable & dishonest terms for ‘AGW doubters’. No educated person disputes global warming, as thermometers measured 1°C rise from 1850 to 2016 (with pauses).

5) The ‘Greenhouse Hypothesis’, on which IPCC’s belief in AGW is based, is that atmospheric gases trap heat. But this old (19th century) notion is merely an idea, not a hypothesis, because it is untestable, impossible to prove in a laboratory as no experimental container can imitate Earth’s uncontained, well-mixed atmosphere.

6) IPCC computer models are so full of assumptions as to be extremely unreliable, e.g. forecast warming for 1995 to 2015 turned out to be 2-3 times too high ! A likely reason is that the greenhouse idea is nonsense, as explained in recent publications by several scientists. See Bullet 19 for an equally drastic failure of IPCC models. See also

https://www.wnd.com/2017/07/study-blows-greenhouse-theory-out-of-the-water/

[and]

https://principia-scientific.org/r-i-p-greenhouse-gas-theory-1980-2018/

7) For about 75% of the last 550 million years, CO2 was 2 to 15 times higher than now. Evolution flourished, CO2 enabling plant photosynthesis, the basis of all life. Extinction events due to overheating by CO2 are unknown.

8) Through the last 12,000 years (our current Holocene interglacial period), CO2 was a mere 250 to 290 ppm (parts per million), near plant-starvation level, until about 1850 when industrial CO2 emissions began, making CO2 climb steeply. Nevertheless CO2 today it is still only 412ppm, i.e. under half of one-tenth of 1% of our atmosphere.

9) Until man began adding CO2 about 1850, warming (determined from ‘proxies’ like tree rings) since the 1600AD Little Ice Age peak was accompanied by slowly rising CO2 (measured in ice cores). A simple explanation is CO2 release by ocean water, whose CO2-holding capacity decreases upon warming.

10) Supporting this sign that CO2 is a consequence, not cause, of global warming, a published study of 1980-2011 measurements showed that changes in warming rate precede changes in CO2’s growth rate, by about a year.

11) Since the 1850 start of man’s additions, CO2’s rise has generally accelerated, without reversals. In stark contrast, the post-1850 to present-day continuance of warming out of the Little Ice Age was interrupted by frequent small coolings of 1-3 years (some relatable to ‘volcanic winters’), plus two 30-year coolings (1878 to 1910, 1944 to 1976), and the famous 1998 to 2013 ‘global-warming pause’ or ‘hiatus’ (Wiki).

12) This unsteady modern warming instead resembles the unsteady rise of the sun’s magnetic output from 1901 toward a rare solar ‘Grand Maximum’ peaking in 1991, the first in 1700 years !

13) Modern warming reached a peak in February 2016. Since then, Earth has cooled for 3 years (now April 2019).

14) The ‘Svensmark Theory’ says increased solar magnetic flux warms Earth by deflecting cosmic rays, thus reducing cloudiness, allowing more of the sun’s warmth to heat the land and ocean instead of being reflected. In support, a NASA study of satellite data spanning 32 years (1979-2011) showed decreasing cloud cover.

15) Vociferous IPCC-involved climate scientist Dr Stefan Rahmstorf (Wiki) of the German government’s Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, recipient of a US$1 million personal research grant from a private foundation, wrongly said in his 2008 article ‘Anthropogenic Climate Change’: "there is no viable alternative ... [to CO2 as driver of modern warming from 1940 to 2005 because] ... different authors agree that solar activity did not significantly increase” during that period. Yet nine years earlier, in 1999, famous physicist Dr Michael Lockwood (Wiki; FRS) wrote, in ‘A Doubling of the Sun’s Coronal Magnetic Field During the Past 100 Years’, published in prestigious Nature journal: "the total magnetic flux leaving the Sun has risen by a factor of 1.4 since 1964” and 2.3 since 1901 !! See for yourselves the striking overall 1964-91 climb in solar-magnetic output, recorded by the strong overall fall in detected neutrons (proportional to cosmic rays), in graph 3 here... 

16) Lockwood showed averaged solar magnetic flux increased 230% from 1901 to 1995, i.e. more than doubled ! The final peak value was 5 times the starting minimum value ! Bullets 17 & 18 likewise back Svensmark’s theory...

17) ... after the previous solar Grand Maximum (4th century, long before industrial CO2), in the next decades Earth warmed to near or above today’s temperature. Then ‘sawtooth’ cooling proceeded, through the Dark Ages and ‘Medieval Warm Period’, into the Little Ice Age, paralleling a 1,000-year unsteady solar decline; and ...

18) ... before that, between 8000 and 2000BC, Earth was occasionally warmer than today for hundreds if not thousands of years, as shown by tree rings, shrunken glaciers, etc.. Then unsteady cooling from 3000BC into the Little Ice Age paralleled unsteady solar decline following the Holocene’s ‘super-Grand’ Maximum near 3000BC.

19) This 4,500-year cooling contradicts IPCC computer models that instead predict warming by the simultaneous (slow) rise in CO2. This is the ‘The Holocene Temperature Conundrum’ of Liu et al. (2014). See also Bullet 6.

20) Embarrassingly for AGW promoters, the 8000-2000BC warm interval (Bullet 18) was already, ironically, named the ‘Holocene Climatic Optimum’, before today’s CO2/AGW hysteria began. The warmth probably benefitted human social development. Indeed, it was cold episodes, bringing drought and famine, that ended civilisations.

21) Cross-correlating post-1880 graphs of solar-magnetic flux versus Earth’s temperature suggests a 25-year time-lag, such that the 2016 peak temperature corresponds to the 1991 solar peak. The lag is probably due to the ocean’s high thermal inertia due to its enormous volume and high heat capacity, hence slow response to warming.

22) IPCC, ignoring the possibility of such a time-lag, claims that simultaneous global warming (until 2016) and solar weakening (since 1991) must mean that warming is driven by CO2 !

23) The last interglacial period about 100,000 years ago was warmer than our Holocene interglacial. Humans and polar bears survived ! CO2 was then about 275ppm, i.e. lower than now (Bullet 8).

24) The simultaneous rise of temperature & CO2 is a ‘spurious correlation’. Warming’s real cause was a solar build-up to a rare Grand Maximum, which man’s industrialisation accompanied by chance. So IPCC demonising CO2 as a ‘pollutant’ is a colossal blunder, costing trillions of dollars in needless & ineffectual efforts to reduce it.

25) Global cooling now in progress since February 2016 can be predicted to last at least 28 years (i.e. to 2044), matching the sun’s 28-year decline from 1991 to today, and allowing for the 25-year time-lag (Bullet 21).

=========

It would certainly seem to be, as Dr. Higgs says, an "inescapable conclusion that the "IPCC is wrong − the sun, not CO2, drove modern global warming".

Well, there you go.

​But let's all pay more for lighting and heating and buy electric cars anyway, because that will, as Trudeau repeats ad nauseum, "grow the economy".

Ca-Ching!!!!!

You may also want to peruse another author's refutation of the IPCC stance; this one being a meteorologist:

A Fatal Flaw in Global Warming Science

Picture
8 Comments
Penny link
8/5/2019 05:24:20 pm

Hi Yaya:

Been so busy these past few days...
this looks like a biggie with lots of links
I'll get to it tomorrow, cause it definitely looks like a goodie :)

Reply
yayacanada
8/5/2019 07:20:50 pm

I thought of you the whole time I was putting it together, Penny. But I also guessed you were busy, so thanks for the stop-by.

Reply
M. Rocknest
8/5/2019 09:11:41 pm

Yaya, that's a great compilation of climate truths Dr. Higgs put together. I'm not qualified to guess but if I had to I would guess we are headed towards global cooling. Here's a copy & paste of a comment I made elsewhere 3 days ago:

<i>As a Canadian I'd actually welcome a warming trend (less devasting than cooling) and I most certainly deplore the illogical carbon tax. Unlike the "science is settled" cadre, I realize climate is so complex as to be, at this point in time, too difficult to predict. It's downright impossible to predict if one assumes CO2 to be the driver of climate change. If you're looking for a driver it would be smarter to look to the sun, the earth's primary heat source, and to the connection between cosmic rays and cloud formation as Henrik Svensmark has done. And never forget that black swan events can unexpectedly and drastically disrupt any global temperature trend -- volcanic eruptions, meteorites, solar flares and heaven forbid nuclear war.

In a million molecules of air there are merely 12 molecules of man-made CO2 and 388 molecules of naturally occurring CO2. It is not a poison and it is absolutely essential to life on earth. It's time to stop maligning this molecule and to focus on methods and technologies which could aid us in adapting to BOTH cooling and warming, whichever trend may emerge in the coming decades.</I>

I later added:

<i>This is my worry ... that focusing attention exclusively onto warming and wasting resources on ill-conceived schemes mankind could end up facing global cooling and not be prepared for it. If the earth is heading into the next ice age I hope it is a slow decline ... slow enough to give mankind time to find some way to survive.</i>

I believe this is something the well-qualified climate expert, Dr. Tim Ball, is worried about too.

Reply
yayacanada
8/5/2019 10:53:42 pm

M.R.: Thanks so much for your input! Tim Ball * is one of the first people that I recall talking about this, years ago. I can't understand what makes the government so adamant that CO2 is the problem, or why so many other people take it as a given, when there has all along been so much professional evidence to the contrary.

I think it's one of the best indicators of the collusion of the media that so many people accept the CO2 theory and fear for the future, especially young kids who should just be having a great time at school.

I recall that David Suzuki used to say that we were heading into an ice age, and then somehow he began to say the opposite. Who got to him, and why did he alter his approach? There's more to what's behind all of this than meets the eye.

*Tim Ball disappointed me bigtime, though, with his crass chauvinism in saying this:
"An Age of Insanity When an Ex-Barmaid Has a National Voice."
https://drtimball.ca/2019/an-age-of-insanity-when-an-ex-barmaid-has-a-national-voice/
Aside from the fact that she graduated from university cum laude, I thought the whole idea of democracy was that people of any "class" in society are free to have opinions and run for office, even if we don't agree with their ideas.

Reply
Penny link
9/5/2019 07:31:47 am

Good Morning Yaya:

going off to get some more coffee before commenting.....

Okay, I'm back :)

I agree that Geologists are most probably the most qualified to discuss the science of climate and it's affects on the planet- which is obviously why they are excluded.

For myself, the biggest factors would be the sun and the oceans. He alludes to the oceans in this comment:

" The lag is probably due to the ocean’s high thermal inertia due to its enormous volume and high heat capacity, hence slow response to warming."

Geofish- who is a geophysicist (retired) had a report up at his place about how it is the creators of the idea of AGW were all English majors (language)- I can't find his post, but, basically it was all PR people and they used the UN to give their sales pitch an air of authority. Thus a campaign was launched!

He's hitting on the idea of correlation not being causation.
Though it's pushed, always as such.
The sun does not rise because the rooster crows (correlation not causation)

M Rocknest: I can't even listen to David Suzuki speak any longer. Way back I liked him, but, he is a sell out.

I'm sure money was involved in his flip

Great Post!

Reply
Penny link
9/5/2019 07:35:20 am

from your last link

"https://edberry.com/blog/climate-physics/agw-hypothesis/preprint-a-fatal-flaw-in-global-warming-science/

"The United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) climate theory assumes nature is constant."

That says all you need to know about the entire theory.
When the foundation is flawed the entire house built on it is flawed and dangerous

Reply
yayacanada
9/5/2019 08:02:38 am

Hi Penny: Thanks for your input. I feel the same about Suzuki as you do. I'm still gagging from those TV commercials he did where he walked into people's homes and removed anything extra they had that was using energy.

Easy to see why geologists have been excluded from the process. And you hit the nail on the head regarding the United Nations - they've made carbon a world-wide issue.

When it becomes obvious they were wrong, they'll just take credit for having prevented the predicted disaster by enforcing carbon reduction -- and corporations will have made a lot of money.

Reply
yayacanada
9/5/2019 08:52:17 am

I guess I'm slow: I just now realized why Suzuki changed his theory. All those TV ads - money, money, money. And, of course, all those awards, Order of Canada, etc. Shame on him for passing himself off as an actual scientist!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture
     



     


    ​PANDEMIC TRUTH

    * * * * * * * * 
    ​----> NEW April 12
    HE'S BACK!
    Dr. Vernon Coleman: We Are the Resistance and We Will Win this War!
    LINK

    April 10

    Sunshine on My Shoulders Makes Me Happy: Lockdowns Kill  LINK
    ​
    See more here:
    PANDEMIC TRUTH 


    * * * * * * * *
    ​​
    RECENT POSTS:
    Climate Propaganda Heating Up Again - 10/04/21
    Liberals Alienating Their Own Supporters
    ​08/04/21
    Raging Pastors, the Anti-Christ, Israel and ... Pixie Dust 06/04/21

    ​​​​OLDER POSTS

    Picture
    Picture
     Photo by Brian O'Connor, North Bay
    ​
    ​​QUOTE of the MONTH:
    ​​"It's easier to fool a person, than it is to convince them they have been fooled."
    Mark Twain
    ​
     LINK

    ​*** NOTICES ***

    HASSAN DIAB CASE
    Injustice expands, need for redress and reform deepens  LINK

    FREE ASSANGE NOW! LINK​
    Follow the trial(s) of
    Julian Assange  LINK

    CANADA HEALTH ALLIANCE LINK 
    Standing Up For Health Freedom!
    ​​
    WORLD FREEDOM ALLIANCE  LINK

    Constitutional Rights Centre Inc.(CRC)  MEDIA LINK
    Prosecutor Rocco Galati on Twitter. LINK

    ​Ontario Civil Liberties Assoc.- OCLA  LINK

    FEARLESS CANADA
    Facebook  LINK

    LEADING CAUSES OF DEATHS IN CANADA
    WorldAtlas - LINK

    Geologist Roger Higgs: ​Global Warming By Surging Sun Not CO2: 4 Slides, 4 Min:​ LINK


    CLIMATE CHANGE? 
    50 Years of Failed Eco-pocalyptic Predictions
    LINK


    CHYCHO LIVE: Current Events and Much More LINK
    ​
    DRUTHERS: If I had my druthers, we all would know the truth - - LINK

    ​
    ---------

    JUSTICE FOR MOHAMED HARKAT:
    PETITION:
    Stop Moe Harkat’s deportation to torture LINK
    Will We Allow Canada To Deport Mohamed Harkat To Torture? ... HuffPost
    The True North Not So Free ... YYC:
    PLEASE ​DONATE
    Moe needs help with his legal costs. Visit 
    here to donate online.
    ​

    -------

    JUSTICE for
    HASSAN DIAB

    Call for Reform of Canada’s Extradition Act Hassan Diab Website

    ​-------
    ​
    PALESTINE

    *
    ​11 examples how IHRA definition threatens free speech and aims to silence Palestinian solidarity... LINK

    PCHR: Israeli Human Rights Violations in the Occupied Palestinian Territory LINK

    ​Israel’s War Criminals in Their Own Words LINK

    Miko Peled: The State of Israel Will Crumble LINK

    Does Israel "own"
    ​America; Netanyahu thinks so. video
    ​

    Jewish Voice for Peace:​​
    Israel Palestine Conflict 101
    video

    ------------------------------
    ​
    INTERESTING PLACES:

    ACTIVIST TEACHER - 
    ... also on Facebook

    Arch. & Eng. for 9/11 Truth
    BDS Movement
    Canada Palestine Assoc.
    CDNs for Justice &        Peace in the Middle East
    CHYCHO
    ClimateChange101

    COAT
    Count Me Out (of census)
    CovertAction Magazine
    Defend Democracy Press
    Dissident Voice

    Elecromagnetic Sense 

    ElNational En 
    End Geoengineering

    Famous Canadian Women
    Friends of Science
    ​GeoEngineering Watch
    GLOBAL RESEARCH

    Gray Zone Project
    Greencrow As The Crow Flies
    IF NOT NOW
    In Gaza, Eva Bartlett
    Information Clearing House
    Israel Palestine News

    Jewish Voice for Peace
    Justice for Mohamed Harkat
    Justice for Hassan Diab
    ​
    LGBTQ+ Online Safety
    OFF-GUARDIAN
    Open Culture
    Open Media
    Opinionated Bastard
    Palestine Photo Project

    PennyforYourThoughts
    Real Climate Science
    Stephen Lendman
    SUSPICIOUS DEATHS
    Truth and Shadows
    Vaccination Info Network
    Vaccine Choice Canada
    Venezuela Analysis
    Watts Up With That?
    WikiLeaks
    YVES ENGLER

    Picture
  • Home
  • About
  • Archive
  • Quotes + Pandemic Truth