Britannica: Michel de Montaigne
Journalist/Mother decries "stupidity" of "anti-vaxxers"
From The Independent:
I have to say, this is one of the most poorly-substantiated articles I have ever read. The author cites "Researchers in the United States" and then instead of sourcing any actual research she links to a short Beckers Hospital (Chicago) blurb that in turn quotes, without a link to any original statement, what Beckers claims is the opinion -- certainly not a research paper -- of a doctor who works at Arnold Palmer hospital in Orlando, Fla.
After clicking a few links on the Arnold Palmer site, I located a blog contribution written by the named "research" source that merely contained information for parents regarding their kids' annual flu shots (provided you click yet another link, this one to a Facebook page), and with no personal research on the part of the author cited, and certainly not the damning opinion boldly presented by Becker's Hospital and thereafter the Independent's journalist.
Shockingly shoddy journalism to be sure, but when you consider the emotional state of the Independent's contributor ...
But, oh for pete's sake, girl - if you allow your children to move out of their playpen you're putting them at risk! If you're feeling helpless, get some emotional counselling. You need to take measures to see that your children are not infected by your fear. And you need to stop trying to infect other mothers with it as well.
Your lack of confidence in the straws you've grasped is revealed when you resort to insults and name-calling in order to dispel the power of the opposite view. You're coming across as more of a rabid anti-antivaxxer-ite than a serious perveyor of ideas and information.
You reduce alternative health practises to the use of "crystals and herbs" when in fact they may well involve more scientific education and knowledge than you yourself possess.
It also seems to make you terribly nervous that:
Is "believed" your word or the "researchers'" word? You believe in the vaccine and some others don't, but why should you feel threatened by the beliefs of others? If you feel safer trusting in drug manufacturers (and keep in mind that your doctor gets his/her information about drugs directly from the manufacturer/profiteer, and not from his/her medical training) what is it to you personally if others don't? How can those others harm you or your family if you are all vaccined up?
Oh, yeah. There's that two week wait until the flu shot starts to work. Well, keep your kids at home if you're that scared, but please don't tell them why. You don't want to produce another set of worried-out-of-their-minds adults.
In fact, keeping the kids at home may actually safeguard others. There's a small chance that your children's nasal flu spray could infect a person with a compromised immune system.
You see, your reasoning for why the flu vaccine can't possibly cause flu is a tad faulty, You don't appear to have heard of "live attenuated influenza vaccine (LAIV)", which admittedly rarely infects others, but does have the capability nevertheless.
Frankly, you come across as more paranoid than knowledgeable:
I feel for you if you're tempted to do without milk for your children, but the truth is bugs and viruses are rife ALL the time. At some point, one has to come to terms with one's environment. In the immortal words of Gilda Radner as Roseanne Roseannadanna:
One also needs to know that "immunised" and "inoculated" are two entirely different concepts. Your child gets "inoculated", but may not necessarily be "immunised".
You don't want to hear, either, that the drug industry is a massive money-maker -- but only if the drugs are sold -- and you are, perhaps unwittingly, doing your bit to that end. Pharmaceutical products, are heavily advertised, just as are household cleaners and cosmetics, but with the added inducement of gut-wrenching fear.
Even your dog has now been added to the flu-shot consumer base.
Your statement that your family's vaccines are "free" is misleading at best. Everyone's tax dollars pay for them, more and more each year. In Canada, our government has no alternative but to pay for each year's version of a flu vaccine, even if it's been assessed as virtually ineffective, because there are "long-term contracts" with purchase orders made out in advance.
Feb. 2018: QZ.com:
And how about an NCBI study done in 2015 that concluded as follows:
It's sad that you feel compelled to use words like "stupidity" and "tin-hat", and to suggest that the world is deeply indebted to Ph.D's just for the rigors of acquiring the title. Clearly, you don't realize, or perhaps don't even want to know, that there are Physicians and Ph.D's among the people you call "stupid" and "tin-hat"?
Check out Vaccine Choice Canada where:
Your insulting language reminds me of a fledgling Born-Again who feels threatened by the evil logic of the non-believer and so has to degrade and deride in order to avoid being influenced. Learn to live and let live just a little bit. And when the flu statistics get you down, consider the number of deaths in vehicle accidents in the United States alone.
You probably allow your children to ride in cars, but what will do you if ever there is a persistent TV campaign, complete with "experts" advocating against doing so, creating guilt and fear in your very soul?
There are people my age (late 70's) who've never had a flu shot and never catch the flu. That's not because they believe in crystals (although that does sound intriguing); it's because they prefer to believe more in the possibility of good health than in the opposite, and they tend not to follow fads.
There are also some who do come down with the flu even though they've had the shot a week or two before. But that's life; that's what it's all about. Aretha Franklin: YouTube
Don't know who said it first -- probably some existentialist -- but the phrase "all events are neutral" is a good one to ponder. It's not what happens; it's our reaction to what happens that creates our reality. Fear can cause us to leap at remedies that may be counter-productive. And it's important to remember that feelings of helplessness, worry and fear are the biggest killers of all.
Try not to pass your fears on to your children. When I was a kid one often heard, "Put on a hat; you'll catch your death of cold." It was all about hats and boots back then; not vaccines. Wonder what it'll be about in another 70 years when we (well, not me) look back and think how naive we all were, thinking that the germs wouldn't eventually win; forgetting that overuse of antibiotics ruined their effectiveness, and people began again to fear hospitals -- as much as they did in the 18th century when puerperal (child-bed) fever was iatrogenic (doctor-induced) -- because of the superbugs now thriving there.
I think it's well worth being reminded of a caution attributed to the I Ching: "Even if all are terrified within 100 miles, the worshipper does not drop the sacred implements."
Peak Oil, Electric Cars and the Coming Ice Age
Stranger than Fiction ... is the truth about the Nobel Prize.
Kids Today, eh? Girls, actually.
The Internet of Just About Everything ... except, maybe, safety.
Where is Superman When You Need Him?
A Tough Cop-Out ... but someone's gotta do it. 08/26/19
Whole Lotta Fakin' Goin' On
Photo: Brian of North Bay
QUOTE of the MONTH:
"Of All the Things I Have Lost, I Miss My Mind the Most." Mark Twain
NEWS & NOTICES:
YYC says: Historically,
when Cons rule Ontario, Libs tend to rule federally.
Nanos Sept. 9: In the vote-rich province of Ontario ... the Libs were the choice of 40 per cent of Ontarians, the Cons 32.3 per cent.
Maclean's Aug. 15:
Libs hold crushing lead in ON; Cons can't win.
Cannibalism for the Climate. Climate Crackpotism Should Be Plainly Obvious Now?
Alberta government orders school boards to remove 'public' from names, raising fears
A truth few dare to utter: Canada will benefit from climate change
Canadian Cultural Information for Visitors
(YYC: Is this you?)
How Chrystia Freeland Organized Donald Trump’s Coup in Venezuela
HuffPost: Will We Allow Canada To Deport Mohamed Harkat To Torture? .....
YYC: The True North Not So Free .....
Moe needs help with his legal costs. Visit here to donate online.
Webcomic & Action
Hassan Diab Website
JUSTICE FOR HASSAN DIAB
Rami Khouri: The U.S. Is Erasing “The Palestinian National Reality From Our World”
Israel’s War Criminals in Their Own Words
Miko Peled: The State of Israel Will Crumble and We Will See A Free Democratic Palestine from the River to the Sea Sooner than Most People Think
Highlights of BDS Impact in 2018
Israel's Shameful Greenwashing - CJPME video
Does Israel "own"
America; Netanyahu thinks so. video
Israel Palestine Conflict 101
Arch. & Eng. for 9/11 Truth
Canada Palestine Assoc.
CDNs for Justice & Peace in the Middle East
CDN's, Arabs, Jews for a Just Peace
Count Me Out
Defend Democracy Press
Deplorable Climate Science
Elecromagnetic Sense ...
Famous Canadian Women
Friends of Science
Gray Zone Project
Greencrow As The Crow Flies
If Americans Knew
If Not Now
In Gaza, Eva Bartlett
Information Clearing House
Jewish Voice for Peace
Justice for Mohamed Harkat
Justice for Hassan Diab
LGBTQ+ Guide to Online Safety
Not a Lot of People Know ... Off-Guardian
Palestine Photo Project
Penny for Your Thoughts
Seriously Free Speech
Truth and Shadows
Vaccination Info Network
Vaccine Choice Canada
Watts Up With That?